Shu'bah reported: Salama bin Kuhail informed me or he informed people and I was among them. He said: I heard Sawaid bin Ghafala who reported: I went out along with Zaid bin Suhan and Salman bin Rabi'a, and found a whip, the rest of the hadith is the same up to the words: "I made use of that." Shu'bah said: I heard him say after ten years, that he made an announcement of it for one year.