It is narrated from Hazrat Harith that a man gifted his mother a slave woman, then he married the woman and gave her to his wife. Then they took their dispute to Hazrat Shurayh. Hazrat Shurayh said to his mother: Surely, your son did not gift you as charity.

Ibrahim declared the slave woman to be the property of the mother, unless he brings a witness that he had given her as dowry before giving her as charity (gift).