Hazrat Mughira narrates that Ibrahim said: A soldier covered a man's head and struck his head with a whip, so Hazrat Shurayh took retribution from him.

29865 - Abu Bakr narrated to us, he said: Abu Khalid narrated to us from Ash'ath from Fudayl from Abdullah ibn Ma'qil who said: I was sitting with Ali when a man came to him and spoke to him privately. Ali said: O Qanbar. The people said: ⦗311⦘ O Qanbar. He said: Take this man out and flog him. Then the flogged man came and said: He has added three lashes to my punishment. Ali said to him: What do you say? He said: He has spoken the truth, O Commander of the Faithful! He said: Take the whip and flog him three lashes. Then he said: O Qanbar! When you flog, do not exceed the prescribed limits.

Hazrat Shaibani states that Hazrat Sha'bi, Hazrat Hakam, and Hazrat Hammad said: Whoever is struck with a whip, a stick, or a stone, and this striking was less than what would cause death intentionally, then this will be considered intentional (murder); its compensation will be retribution (qisas).