Hazrat Shabak narrates that a woman obtained some rings from someone for use. One day, when she was about to perform ablution, she placed the rings in her lap, and the rings fell somewhere. This case was brought before the court of Qazi Shurayh. It was said to him that she had taken these rings as a loan to return them, but now she has violated the agreement. Hazrat Shurayh held her liable for them.

Ibrahim says that there is no liability upon the one who rents something or borrows it, but if they go against the agreement, then there is liability.

Hazrat Hakam and Hazrat Hammad did not consider there to be any guarantee (liability) for a borrowed (loaned) item.

Hasan says that when the borrower of a loaned item goes against the agreement, he will be liable.

Hazrat Ata says that there is liability for borrowed (loaned) items.

Hazrat Ibn Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both) used to prescribe liability for borrowed (loaned) items, and according to Ibn Jurayj, when the owner demands it.

21782 - Ibn Jurayj added: If its owner (followed it). (1) (2).

Hazrat Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) says that a loaned item is neither a sale nor does it carry liability; it is an act of kindness. However, if the user goes against the agreement, then liability will apply.

Ibrahim was asked about a man who borrowed a horse, and when he spurred the horse, it died. He replied that there will be no liability, because a man usually spurs a horse.

Hazrat Masrooq used to stipulate liability for borrowed (loaned) items.