33330 - Abu Bakr said: So this is, according to the statement of Umar, Abdullah, and Zayd, out of three shares: for the grandfather one third, and what remains is for the siblings; and according to the statement of Ali, out of six shares: for the grandfather one sixth, one share, and for the siblings five shares.

Ibrahim narrates the statement of Hazrat Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him) that in the case of a sister and a grandfather, both will receive half each.

Fudayl narrates from Ibrahim regarding the issue that if a man leaves behind his grandfather and real brother, then according to the statements of Ali, Abdullah, and Zaid (may Allah be pleased with them), both the grandfather and the brother will be entitled to half of the wealth each. And regarding the man who leaves behind his grandfather and two real brothers, these personalities state that the grandfather will receive one-third of the wealth and the brothers will receive two-thirds of the wealth. Abu Bakr (may Allah be pleased with him) states that this issue will be resolved in two parts: in the case where among the heirs there is a sister or brother and a grandfather, then the grandfather will receive half of the wealth, and the sister or brother will also receive half of the wealth. And if the heirs are two brothers instead of one, then the grandfather will receive one-third of the wealth and both brothers will receive two-thirds of the wealth.

33333 - Abu Bakr said: So this is from (two shares) (1) if there is a sister or a brother and a grandfather, then the grandfather gets half and the sister or brother gets half, and if there are two brothers, then the grandfather gets one third and the two brothers get two thirds.

Ibrahim says that when a man dies leaving behind his grandfather and real nephew, then according to the decision of Hazrat Ali (may Allah be pleased with him), Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him), and Zaid (may Allah be pleased with him), the wealth will go to the grandfather. This issue will be resolved from one share only, meaning all the wealth will be for the grandfather.

33335 - (Abu Bakr said) (1): So this is from one share, and it is the entire wealth] (2).

Ibrahim says regarding the man who dies leaving his grandfather, full brother, and paternal half-brother: the grandfather will receive half of the estate, and the full brother will receive the other half. This is the opinion of Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) and Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him). Zaid (may Allah be pleased with him) used to give the grandfather one third of the estate and the full brother two thirds. In the division, he included the paternal half-brother with the full brother, but did not make the paternal half-brother an heir.

Ibrahim says that Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him) used to include the grandfather with the brothers in the division of wealth, and used to give every rightful person his due, and would not make the maternal brother an heir in the presence of the grandfather, and in the case of the participation of full brothers with the grandfather in the division, he would not give the paternal brother a share in the division, and when a full sister, a paternal sister, and the grandfather were together, he would give half the wealth to the full sister and half to the grandfather. And Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) used to include the grandfather with the brothers in the division of wealth up to one-sixth, and would give every rightful person his due, and would not make the maternal brother an heir in the presence of the grandfather, and in the presence of children, would not give the grandfather more than one-sixth of the wealth, except if there was no other heir besides the grandfather. So when a full sister, a paternal brother and sister, and the grandfather were together, he would give half the wealth to the full sister and include the brother and sister with the grandfather in the division. Abu Bakr says that this issue will be resolved in two ways according to the statements of Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) and Abdullah (may Allah be pleased with him), and in three ways according to the statement of Zaid (may Allah be pleased with him).

33338 - Abu Bakr said: So this, according to the statement of Ali and Abdullah, is from two shares, and according to the statement of Zayd, from three shares.

Muhammad bin Sirin narrates that Ubaidullah bin Ziyad intended to make a uterine sister an heir in the presence of the grandfather, and he said that Hazrat Umar (may Allah be pleased with him) had made a uterine sister an heir along with the grandfather. So Hazrat Abdullah bin Utbah said: "I am neither a Saba'i nor a Khariji, therefore you should follow the hadith, because as long as you follow the hadith, you will not go astray from the straight path."